Pose estimation and classification on edge devices with MoveNet and TensorFlow Lite
8월 16, 2021

Posted by Khanh LeViet, TensorFlow Developer Advocate and Yu-hui Chen, Software Engineer

The MoveNet iOS sample has been released. Check it out on GitHub.

Since MoveNet’s announcement at Google I/O earlier this year, we have received a lot of positive feedback and feature requests. Today, we are excited to share several updates with you:

  • The TensorFlow Lite version of MoveNet is now available on TensorFlow Hub. This includes a few updates to improve accuracy and make it compatible with hardware accelerators including GPUs and other accelerators available via the Android NN API.
  • We’ve released a new Android, Raspberry Pi pose estimation sample that lets you try out MoveNet on mobile and IoT devices. (iOS is coming soon)
  • We’ve also released a Colab notebook that teaches you how to do custom pose classification (e.g. recognize different yoga poses) with MoveNet. You can try pose classification on the Android, iOS and Raspberry Pi apps mentioned earlier.

What is pose estimation?

Gif of pose estimation using machine learning

Pose estimation is a machine learning task that estimates the pose of a person from an image or a video by estimating the spatial locations of specific body parts (keypoints). MoveNet is the state-of-the-art pose estimation model that can detect these 17 key-points:

  • Nose
  • Left and right eye
  • Left and right ear
  • Left and right shoulder
  • Left and right elbow
  • Left and right wrist
  • Left and right hip
  • Left and right knee
  • Left and right ankle

We have released two versions of MoveNet:

  • MoveNet.Lightning is smaller, faster but less accurate than the Thunder version. It can run in realtime on modern smartphones.
  • MoveNet.Thunder is the more accurate version but also larger and slower than Lightning.

The MoveNet models outperform Posenet (paper, blog post, model), our previous TensorFlow Lite pose estimation model, on a variety of benchmark datasets (see the evaluation/benchmark result in the table below).

These MoveNet models are available in both the TensorFlow Lite FP16 and INT8 quantized formats, allowing maximum compatibility with hardware accelerators.

This version of MoveNet can recognize a single pose from the input image. If there is more than one person in the image, the model along with the cropping algorithm will try its best to focus on the person who is closest to the image center. We have also implemented a smart cropping algorithm to improve the detection accuracy on videos. In short, the model will zoom into the region where there’s a pose detected in the previous frame, so that the model can see the finer details and make better predictions in the current frame.

If you are interested in a deep-dive into MoveNet’s implementation details, check out an earlier blog post including its model architecture and the dataset it was trained on.

Sample app for Android and Raspberry Pi

We have released new pose estimation sample apps for these platforms so that you can quickly try out different pose estimation models (MoveNet Lightning, MoveNet Thunder, Posenet) on the platform of your choice.

  • Android sample
  • iOS sample
  • Raspberry Pi sample

In the Android and iOS sample, you can also choose an accelerator (GPU, NNAPI, CoreML) to run the pose estimation models.

Screenshot of the Android sample app. The image is from Pixabay.

Screenshot of the Android sample app. The image is from Pixabay.

MoveNet performance

We have optimized MoveNet to run well on hardware accelerators supported by TensorFlow Lite, including GPU and accelerators available via the Android NN API. This performance benchmark result may help you choose the runtime configurations that are most suitable for your use cases.

Model

Size (MB)

mAP*

Latency (ms) **

Pixel 5 - 
CPU 4 threads

Pixel 5 - GPU

Raspberry Pi 4 - CPU 4 threads

MoveNet.Thunder (FP16 quantized)

12.6MB

72.0

155ms

45ms

594ms

MoveNet.Thunder (INT8 quantized)

7.1MB

68.9

100ms

52ms

251ms

MoveNet.Lightning (FP16 quantized)

4.8MB

63.0

60ms

25ms

186ms

MoveNet.Lightning (INT8 quantized)

2.9MB

57.4

52ms

28ms

95ms

PoseNet
(MobileNetV1 backbone, FP32)

13.3MB

45.6

80ms

40ms

338ms

* mAP was measured on a subset of the COCO keypoint dataset where we filter and crop each image to contain only one person.

** Latency was measured end-to-end using the Android and Raspberry Pi sample apps with TensorFlow 2.5 under sustained load.

Here are some tips when deciding which model and accelerator to use:

  • Choose Lightning or Thunder. Firstly, you should see whether the accuracy of the Lightning version is enough for your use case.
    • If the Lightning INT8 model’s accuracy is good enough, then go with it because it’s the smallest and fastest model in the lineup. A faster model also means less battery consumed.
    • If having good accuracy is critical for your use case, go with the Thunder FP16 model.
  • Choose the accelerator. Accelerator performance varies a lot between Android devices from different manufacturers.
    • CPU is the safest and simplest choice because you can know for sure that it will work on practically any Android device that can run TensorFlow Lite. However, it is usually slower and consumes more power than running the model on accelerators. All MoveNet models can run well on CPU so you should choose a model based on your accuracy needs.
    • GPU is the most widely available accelerator and provides a decent performance boost. Choose the FP16 quantized models if you want to leverage GPUs.
    • Android NNAPI is the convenient way to access additional ML accelerators on Android devices. If you are already using the CPU or GPU for other workloads and your user’s device runs Android 10 or a newer version, you can choose a model that suits your accuracy needs, and let NNAPI choose the path that it thinks works best for your model.
    • If you are an IoT developer, you may want to use Coral to increase inference speed. See the benchmark numbers for Coral here.
  • Deploy the model over-the-air rather than bundle it in the app binary. Due to the variety of the Android ecosystem, there’s no single model that is optimal for all of your users. For users with lower-end devices, the Lightning INT8 model might be optimal for them because it’s the fastest and consumes the least battery. However, for users with high-end devices, you may want to deliver better performance using the Thunder FP16 model. If you want to change models according to the user device, consider using the free Firebase ML to host your models instead of bundling all the models you intend to use into your app. You can write a logic to download an optimal model for each of your user’s device when the user starts using a feature in your app that requires the TFLite model.

Pose classification

While the pose estimation model tells you where the pose key points are, in many fitness applications, you may want to go further and classify the pose, for example whether it’s a yoga goddess pose or a plank pose, to deliver relevant information to your users.

To make pose classification easier to implement, we’ve also released a Colab notebook that teaches you how to use MoveNet and TensorFlow Lite to train a custom pose classification model from your custom pose dataset. It means that if you want to recognize yoga poses, all you need is to collect images of poses that you want to recognize, label them, and follow the tutorial to train and deploy a yoga pose classifier into your applications.

The pose classifier consists of two stages:

  1. Use MoveNet to detect keypoints from the input image.
  2. Use a small TensorFlow Lite model to classify the pose from the detected keypoints.
An example of pose classification using MoveNet. The input image is from Pixabay.

An example of pose classification using MoveNet. The input image is from Pixabay.

In order to train a custom pose classifier, you need to prepare the pose images and put them into a folder structure as below. Each subfolder name is the name of the class you want to recognize. Then you can run the notebook to train a custom pose classifier and convert it to the TensorFlow Lite format.

yoga_poses
|__ downdog
    |______ 00000128.jpg
    |______ 00000181.bmp
    |______ ...
|__ goddess
    |______ 00000243.jpg
    |______ 00000306.jpg
    |______ ...
...

The pose classification TensorFlow Lite model is very small, only about 30KBs. It takes the landmarks output from MoveNet, normalizes the pose coordinates and feeds it through a few fully connected layers. The model output is a list of probabilities that the pose is each of the known pose types.

Overview of the pose classification TensorFlow Lite model
Overview of the pose classification TensorFlow Lite model.

You can try your pose classification model in any of the pose estimation sample apps for Android or Raspberry Pi that we have just released.

What’s next

Our goal is to provide the core pose estimation and action recognition engine so that developers can build creative applications on top of it. Here are some of the directions that we are actively working on:

  • An improved version of MoveNet that can detect multiple poses in one forward path.
  • Action recognition based on the detected poses on multiple frames.

Please let us know via tflite@tensorflow.org or the TensorFlow Forum if you have any feedback or suggestions!

Acknowledgements

We would like to thank the other contributors to MoveNet: Ronny Votel, Ard Oerlemans, Francois Belletti along with those involved with the TensorFlow Lite: Tian Lin, Lu Wang.

Next post
Pose estimation and classification on edge devices with MoveNet and TensorFlow Lite

Posted by Khanh LeViet, TensorFlow Developer Advocate and Yu-hui Chen, Software EngineerThe MoveNet iOS sample has been released. Check it out on GitHub. Since MoveNet’s announcement at Google I/O earlier this year, we have received a lot of positive feedback and feature requests. Today, we are excited to share several updates with you: The TensorFlow Lite version of MoveNet is now available on